Skip to the stories
Saturday, 21 November 2026
Saved

Next edition

12:57

Headlines

Recipes in the News

Historical Records Clarify the Authentic Menu of the 1621 Plymouth Feast

Historical accounts confirm that the 1621 Plymouth harvest celebration relied on wild game and local provisions rather than modern Thanksgiving staples.

FTMQ Food, written by our newsroom0 views

Share
Picture: Taste of Home

Taste of Home reported that historical records contain remarkably few details regarding the specific menu served during the first Thanksgiving in Plymouth in the autumn of 1621. The feast brought together approximately 50 English colonists and 90 Wampanoag people to mark their first successful harvest. The Wampanoag attendees included their leader Ousamequin, who is historically known as Massasoit. [1]

While wild turkey is popular in modern tradition, Taste of Home reported that written documentation from the event mentions five deer provided for the gathering. The event lasted three days and involved roughly 140 people. No participant recorded a complete menu during the gathering. [1]

The retelling of the 1621 harvest feast as the primary foundation for the modern holiday has been criticized by academic scholars and Indigenous peoples in the United States. Historical analysis shows that many modern Thanksgiving foods were absent from the original feast. The narrative traditionally surrounding the interaction between English settlers and regional Indigenous populations obfuscates the broader history of the area. [3]

In the United States, Thanksgiving is observed annually as a federal holiday on the fourth Thursday of November. The date ranges from November 22 to November 28 depending on the calendar year. Family dinners remain the primary focus of the national holiday. [2]

Share

In short

  • The 1621 Plymouth harvest gathering included approximately 50 English colonists and 90 Wampanoag.
  • Historical records confirm five deer were brought to the three-day Plymouth feast.
  • Scholars point out that many modern Thanksgiving items were not eaten at the 1621 event.
  • Thanksgiving is celebrated in the United States on the fourth Thursday of November.

Sources

Every paragraph above points to the numbered items it rests on. Read the originals here.

  1. [1]This Is What Was on the Menu at the First Thanksgiving in 1621Taste of Home, 17h ago (the report this story comes from)

Background

  1. [2]Thanksgiving (United States) on Wikipedia
  2. [3]Myth of the First Thanksgiving on Wikipedia
  3. [4]Menu on Grokipedia

Our newsroom writes these reports with the help of software, from the 4 sources listed and nothing else, and checks them against those sources. Facts can still be wrong or move on; the originals are the record. Spotted a mistake? Write to daniel@monsterkong.com.

More in Recipes in the News

Get the day in one email

Reports like this one, the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning. Free, one email a day; readers can comment under every report.

By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.

Comments

Loading

Join the conversation

Comments are open to readers of our daily email: the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning, free. Sign up and the comment box opens.

Already on the list? Enter the same address and we will send a sign-in link.

By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.